“Don’t make assumptions about what a particular generation looks like,” said Susan Bridges Gilder, director of total rewards at Beiersdorf. “We need to get beyond labels and really need to get into what individual people need.”

Gilder spoke on an executive panel discussion about this topic at From Day One’s NYC half-day benefits conference. Panelists discussed how they are supporting a workforce that spans five generations. The session, titled “Inclusive Well-Being Strategies for a Multigenerational Workforce,” quickly landed on a consensus to stop trying to put employees in a box.

From Demographics to 'Moments That Matter'

Tania Rahman, moderator and social director at Fast Company, opened the discussion by noting the breadth of needs in today's workforce. A Gen Z employee might be focused on student debt, while a Baby Boomer is more concerned about their pensions.

“For me, it’s not even generations, it’s really about the moments that matter,” Maria Julieta Casanova, the global head of strategic HR business partners and talent acquisition COE at Corteva Agriscience, said. She notes that potential hires now ask more questions regarding their benefits, like fertility support or parental leave for dads, than about their salaries.

“Those are the moments that we need to focus on,” she added. “It’s our job to make sure that people stay while they navigate through the complexities of life.”

Sometimes the moments that matter exist within the workplace. Lesley Alderman, a Brooklyn-based psychotherapist, has a client who was miserable working in their company's open-plan office. Alderman offered a simple solution that was immediately rejected: wear headphones.

“No one does that. I’m going to be stigmatized,” the client thought. This fear of standing out is one of the silent killers of employee well-being. It’s a problem no single benefit package can fit, but a culture of inclusive leadership just might, she says. 

Sarah Royal, the senior director of marketing at the family care platform Cleo, challenged the audience to consider the commonality all employees share beneath the surface.

“We often get caught up in that generational conversation of saying they’re so different,” she said. “But I would venture to say that, for the most part, if we asked what are the top three most important things in your life, probably most of you would say somebody that you're caring for.”

The Preventive Approach to Mental Health

Alderman says feelings of uncertainty are the primary reason many people seek therapy. Any benefits that make it easier for employees to navigate their world provide a sense of control, whether it’s financial planning, onsite services, or caregiving support.

Casanova echoed this, sharing a story of a senior executive candidate who negotiated for more vacation time, a move she calls a “breath of fresh air” that signaled a cultural shift. “The more we can bring leaders and really encourage them to make good use of the benefits available, the more this will cascade and become part of the culture,” she said. 

Gilder highlighted the importance of preventive mental health. Companies shouldn't wait until employees are broken to offer support, she says. Beiersdorf has been working on a resilience series with the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) and joined an employers' collaborative in New York City to foster ongoing conversations.

Gilder also championed the idea of a dedicated caregiving benefit, pointing to Cleo as an example of a service that acts as a guide for employees navigating life events, from raising children to caring for aging parents. “It’s not like the EAP where you just get a random person,” Gilder pointed out. “You have someone assigned to you, and you build that connection.”

Building Trust Through Utilization and Communication

You can design the most generous benefits package in the world, but if your employees don’t use it, you’ve wasted your time and money. Michelle Randazzo, the total rewards retirement benefits lead at AlixPartners, says that the work doesn’t end with rolling out a great program. “Employees need to be educated on their benefits so that they can make educated decisions, and that still remains an issue," she said.

To combat this, AlixPartners focuses on building trust through personal connection. To bridge the gap between benefits and utilization, Randazzo leads a neurodiverse employee resources group (ERG), and she’s candid about her experience with ADHD. She maintains a 25-page 401(k) FAQ that ends with a simple but powerful prompt to send her an email if they still have unanswered questions.

“The magic actually happens when you meet your people in person,” she added. “They feel valued, and that builds trust, and when you build trust, they will then be part of the process.”

Royal added that the most effective marketing for a benefit often comes from peers. “Have the people leaders, the managers, be human, use the benefits themselves,” she said.

Ultimately, it was unanimously agreed that the most successful strategies treat employees as whole human beings who are navigating their complex lives. As Randazzo put it, “If all you care about is cost containment, then we are not dealing with humans. We are dealing with data, and people are not robots.”

Ade Akin covers artificial intelligence, workplace wellness, HR trends, and digital health solutions.

(Photos by Josh Larson for From Day One)